Spicy Tomato Vodka Pasta with Italian Sausage

This post may contain affiliate links. See my Affiliate Disclosure for more details.

This Spicy Tomato Vodka Pasta with Italian Sausage is one of those recipes that came together completely on a whim. We are a pasta-loving family, so it’s not uncommon for me to look through the refrigerator and pantry and throw together some kind of pasta dish based on what we already have in the house.

And that is exactly how this one happened.

I had fresh tomatoes and mini bell peppers that needed to be used, a jar (and a little extra) of spicy vodka sauce, heavy cream, Parmesan, and pasta in the pantry. I originally made it with ground turkey because that’s what I had on hand, added a few dollops of basil pesto at the end, and hoped for the best.

Everyone loved it.

It was one of those dinners where I immediately knew I needed to remember exactly what I did so I could make it again. And after making a few small tweaks—swapping the ground turkey for sweet Italian sausage and adding creamy ricotta with the pesto on top—it officially became a new family favorite and one that will absolutely be added to our monthly dinner rotation.

The sauce is creamy and slightly spicy, but still has plenty of texture from the fresh tomatoes, sweet bell peppers, onion, and Italian sausage. Then the ricotta and basil pesto on top add little pockets of creamy, fresh flavor that make the whole dish even better.

A Pasta Recipe Made With What I Had

Some of my favorite dinners are the ones I don't really plan. And since we eat pasta pretty regularly, I almost always have a few different noodles on-hand. Then I’ll add whatever vegetables, protein, cheese, or other ingredients we happen to have and turn it into dinner.

For this recipe, I started by cooking down onion, mini sweet peppers, garlic, and whole tomatoes. Rather than using the vodka sauce by itself, the fresh vegetables become part of the sauce and give it a chunkier, more homemade texture. From there, I added Carbone Spicy Vodka Sauce and heavy cream, tossed everything with cavatappi and Italian sausage, and finished it with freshly grated Parmesan and a little reserved pasta water.

The ricotta and pesto are technically toppings, but I highly recommend both. The ricotta adds a cool creaminess against the spicy tomato sauce, while the pesto gives you the fresh basil flavor in little bites throughout the bowl.

How to Make Spicy Tomato Vodka Pasta with Italian Sausage

For the full recipe, please see the recipe card below.

Jump to Recipe

• Cook the Italian sausage: Drizzle olive oil on a large pan over medium heat, then add the sweet Italian sausage. Break it into smaller pieces as it cooks, then remove it from the pan once browned and cooked through. Place meat aside.
• Cook the vegetables: In the same pan (after removing the meat), add the sliced onion and mini bell peppers. Cook for about four to five minutes, adding a small drizzle of olive oil, if needed.
• Add the garlic: Stir in the grated garlic (after onions and peppers!) and cook for another 30–60 seconds, just until fragrant. Add an extra clove or two if you're feeling a little frisky… or just want to keep someone at a distance.
• Add the tomatoes: Place the whole tomatoes directly into the pan with the vegetables. Drizzle them with a little extra virgin olive oil and season with salt and black pepper.
• Let the tomatoes simmer: Cover and reduce the heat to low, and let everything simmer for approximately 20 minutes. As the tomatoes soften, mash them directly into the pan to create a chunky tomato sauce. (I prefer to keep the tomato skins for texture).
• Cook the pasta: While the tomatoes are simmering, cook the cavatappi until just shy of al dente. Before draining, reserve at least 1/2 cup of the pasta water. (I save about 1 cup, just in case I need extra or am low on sauce).
• Make it creamy: Add the Carbone spicy vodka sauce and heavy cream to the tomato mixture, then return the cooked Italian sausage to the pan. Stir everything together over low heat.
• Add the pasta: Add the drained cavatappi directly to the sauce and toss until everything is well coated.
• Finish with Parmesan: Sprinkle the freshly grated Parmesan over the pasta, then pour approximately 1/4 cup of hot reserved pasta water over the cheese. Toss everything together until the Parmesan melts and the sauce becomes creamy. Add another splash of pasta water if needed.
• Add the toppings: Spoon the pasta into bowls and finish with dollops of ricotta and basil pesto. Add a little extra freshly grated Parmesan on top because, obviously.

The pasta water is especially helpful here because the exact amount of vodka sauce really doesn’t need to be perfect. I used what I already had in my refrigerator, which ended up being somewhere around 28 ounces. If you use closer to 24 ounces and the pasta seems a little drier than you’d like, just add a little more reserved pasta water until the sauce reaches the consistency you prefer.

Is This Pasta Really Spicy?

I should probably preface this by saying that I am a bit of a wimp when it comes to spicy food. Truly…

Carbone’s Spicy Vodka Sauce definitely gives this pasta some heat, but the heavy cream, fresh tomatoes, Parmesan, and ricotta all help balance it out. For me, it has enough spice to give the sauce some flavor without completely overpowering everything else. Might make your nose run just a bit, if you're anything like me 🙂

That being said, you can absolutely make this with Carbone’s Classic Vodka Sauce instead. If you're cooking for kids or anyone who doesn't love spice, the classic vodka sauce would be my first swap. Honestly, I think it would be just as delicious!

Why I Use Cavatappi Pasta

Technically, you can make this recipe with whatever pasta you prefer or have in the pantry. Again, this entire recipe was born from using what I already had, so I am certainly not going to tell you that you need one specific noodle.

But I love cavatappi for creamy sauces.

The little corkscrew shape catches the tomato vodka sauce, pieces of Italian sausage, peppers, and Parmesan instead of everything falling to the bottom of the bowl. It also holds up really well to finishing the pasta directly in the sauce without becoming too soft.

Rigatoni, penne, fusilli, or another short pasta would all work well too.

Easy Substitutions and Additions

This is already a very forgiving recipe, so don't stress if you don't have every exact ingredient I used.

• Don't like spicy food? Use Carbone Classic Vodka Sauce instead of the spicy version. You’ll still get the creamy tomato vodka flavor without as much heat.
• Prefer a different protein? I originally made this recipe with ground turkey, and it was delicious. Ground chicken would work too, sweet Italian chicken sausage, even lobster. Or you can leave the meat out altogether.
• Don't have mini bell peppers? A regular red, orange, or yellow bell pepper will work just fine. I would just thinly slice them.
• Don't have cavatappi? Use another short pasta like rigatoni, penne, or fusilli.
• Want it extra creamy? Add another spoonful of ricotta when serving or a small splash of additional heavy cream to the sauce. If you don't like ricotta, fresh burrata would be my next choice!
• Have fresh basil? Absolutely add it. You can sprinkle fresh basil over the finished pasta or use it along with the pesto.

And when it comes to the amount of sauce, 24–32 ounces is completely fine. This is not one of those recipes where being a few ounces off is going to ruin dinner. Start with what you have, and use that reserved pasta water to loosen everything up, if needed.

My Favorite Ingredient Brands to Use

I have no affiliation with any of these brands, I just personally love them!

You can absolutely use whatever brands you already have or prefer, but these are the ingredients I personally reach for when making this pasta:

• Carbone Spicy Vodka Sauce – This is the base I used when I first made the recipe, and I love the flavor it gives the finished sauce. If you don't love spice, their Classic Vodka Sauce works perfectly here too.
• De Cecco Cavatappi – Cavatappi is one of my favorite pasta shapes for a creamy, chunky sauce like this because all of those little curves hold onto everything.
• Premio Sweet Italian Sausage – I love sweet Italian sausage here because it adds a ton of flavor without adding even more heat to the dish. Johnsonville, Applegate, even Kroger brand are just as good though.
• BelGioioso Ricotta con Latte – This is what I like to use for those creamy dollops on top. You don't need a ton—the ricotta is really there to add little creamy bites throughout the pasta.
• Gotham Greens Basil Pesto – One of my favorite store-bought pestos when I don't have fresh basil or homemade pesto around. I also love the pesto from Costco.
• California Olive Ranch Extra Virgin Olive Oil – This is my go-to olive oil for cooking the vegetables and drizzling over the fresh tomatoes as they simmer.
• Organic Produce – I typically use organic tomatoes, mini sweet peppers, onion, and garlic when I can. There isn't one specific produce brand you need for this recipe—just use what looks fresh and what you already have available.

A Few Tips Before You Make It

There are really only a few things I’d keep in mind when making this pasta.

1. First, don't rush the tomatoes. Giving them time to soften and cook down with the onions, peppers, and garlic is what turns those individual ingredients into the fresh tomato base for the sauce.
2. Second, save your pasta water before draining the noodles. I know this is the easiest step in the world to forget, but it really does make a difference here. The starchy water helps melt the Parmesan into the sauce and gives you an easy way to adjust the consistency at the very end.
3. And finally, freshly grated Parmesan is worth it. It melts much more smoothly into the pasta than pre-shredded Parmesan and helps give the finished sauce that creamy texture. Grab that block of cheese and grate it yourself!

Final Thoughts

I love when a completely unplanned dinner turns into something everyone immediately asks me to make again.

This Spicy Tomato Vodka Pasta with Italian Sausage started as a way to use up what I already had in the refrigerator and pantry, and somehow ended up becoming one of our new favorite pasta dinners. It’s creamy, a little spicy, full of fresh tomatoes and vegetables, and topped with ricotta and pesto—which might be my favorite part.

And more importantly, it's forgiving. Use the pasta you have. Swap the spicy vodka sauce for classic. Use ground turkey instead of sausage. Add a little more pasta water if you need it. This is very much a use what you have and make it work kind of dinner, which is exactly how it started in the first place.

Enjoy, friends! If you try this Spicy Tomato Vodka Pasta with Italian Sausage, I’d love to know what you think!

If You Liked (or Loved) This Recipe…

I'd love to see it! Send me a message @ItsHannahCallahan or tag me on your Instagram post or story with a picture! You can also leave comments below telling me how you liked (or loved) it, and if you made any substitutions!

---